Gilead top brass still missing despite desperate search efforts

5
SHARE
The world's deepest cave, Krubera Cave in Georgia

Dear readers, we are distressed to inform you that the leadership team of Gilead Sciences in Australia appears to have gone missing in the wilds of “overseas”.

After michaelwest.com.au touched base last week to discuss the tax affairs of the giant US pharma company in Australia, spokesperson Andrea said the team was overseas and unable to be contacted. Days passed.

We expressed concern to Andrea on Friday and yesterday about Team Gilead and inquired as to their whereabouts and well-being. Alas there was no word. They were still completely uncontactable … overseas somewhere.

Did they not have mobile phones and broadband overseas? Surely, they must be in an exotic locale. Could it be the Sahara Desert? Unlikely; mobile communications in Chad and Niger are slow and patchy but the internet is slow and patchy in Australia too. In fact it was very slow and patchy at this very desk last night.

Perhaps the G-Team was climbing Mount Everest and therefore unavailable for comment because there was no mobile reception in the Death Zone. No, we can rule that out. We soon discovered that hanks to Huawei and China Mobile – Everest is now wired all the way to the summit.

If it were another season, it might be plausible the Gilead leadership team was uncontactable in Antarctica. There is no mobile reception in Antarctica but travelling there in winter is impossible so we scratched Antarctica from the list.

That left one place on the planet: the Grubera Cave in the Republic of Georgia, The deepest cave in the world. According to a BBC report, The last places on Earth without the internet, it would be difficult to get mobile reception in the Grubera Cave, particularly in the lower echelons as, at a depth of 1.71 kilometres below the surface, the Grubera Cave is a very deep cave.

Could it be that Gilead directors Mr R Hetherington, Ms R Washington, Mr B Pletcher and Dr R Ertl – along with Gilead’s chief financial officer and other executives – are on a speleological expedition beneath the earth in Georgia, Stalin’s old stomping ground?

The uncomfortable truth is we just don’t know and so our thoughts and prayers go out to the friends and family of Team Gilead at this difficult time.

There is one other possibility. It may be that Team Gilead is not really uncontactable but rather … hiding. We have discounted this possibility as it would suggests sly behaviour.

Looking at the company’s financial statements however, sly and foxy behaviour cannot be ruled out. Like other Big Pharma companies, Gilead receives enormous taxpayer subsidies via the Pharmaceutical Benefits Scheme (PBS) but then pays a pittance in corporate income tax, funnelling its profits from Australia offshore.

Although Gilead booked $2.3 billion in cash receipts from its customers in Australia last year, it paid just $2.8 million in income tax and over the past six years, tax as a percentage of revenue is 0.82 per cent – correct, they are paying less than one per cent of their sales – after billion dollar subsidies via the PBS.

Lending further plausibility to this theory of slyness and failure to be accountable, another top ten global pharma company Abbvie was also contacted for comment on its financials more than a week ago but the status of the response from spokesperson Lisa remains:

“Thanks Michael – also just to let you know I have had to refer to the US team who manage (sic) this. I will keep you posted.”

This response neatly reflects two points: 1. there is no accountability by multinationals and their advisers, and 2. the real directors, “shadow directors”, are offshore pulling the strings and so the local entity should be taxed as such, treated like an agency rather than a body corporate.

Multinational sham: how Australia was hoodwinked

Postscript: Gilead was contacted on July 6 with a list of questions. It failed to answer every question and responded with an irrelevant statement.

QUESTIONS FOR GILEAD

Just looking at the past six years of Gilead financial statements in Australia and have a few questions for the company:

1. Can you confirm the parent company of Gilead Sciences Pty Ltd is Gilead Sciences ltd or Gilead Sciences Ireland UC.
2. Please explain how you recognise cash receipts from customers of $2.3B on sales revenue of $483m?
3. Can you explain how payments to suppliers and employees are $1.6B when costs of sales and employee benefits are only $441m?
4. The average salary is $230k according to your accounts. Please explain why it is so high? Is this below or above industry average, or a mistake?
5. P19 of 2016 referred to a ‘provision for rebates” of over $1b but the balance sheet only shows provisions of 1.5m. Please explain.
6. Do you have any financial assets at fair value through the P&L or available for sale as investments at year end?
7. Please explain why there is no allowance for doubtful debts on trade debtors of $385m. Are sales guaranteed?
RESPONSE FROM GILEAD

Please attribute this statement to a spokesperson from Gilead Sciences, ANZ. 

10 July 2017: Gilead Sciences statement to Michael West
Gilead Sciences, Inc. is a research-based biopharmaceutical company that discovers, develops and commercialises innovative, life-saving medicines in areas of unmet medical need. Gilead’s most recent PBS listings are for new hepatitis C treatments. The Australian Government has taken a world-leading approach to providing broad access to these medicines, which has the potential to eradicate hepatitis C in Australia.Gilead works closely with the Department of Health to reach agreements that provide access to its medicines. As is the case for many PBS listed products, some medicines are listed on the basis of complex, multi-year funding arrangements. These agreements may include rebate and reimbursement schedules, and the details of these arrangement are confidential. It is not accurate to draw conclusions about financial information and taxation arrangements based on PBS sales of Gilead medicines in Australia.Gilead Australia takes its tax obligations seriously and determines its tax liability in accordance with Australian tax laws, with tax calculated on taxable income.

  • Hazel Heal

    Gold.

    • Rainer the cabbie

      Found deep underground. No wonder they couldn’t be contacted.

  • James Freeman

    They are probably holed up with Maxwell Smart and The Chief in the offices of Ernst&Young in the cone of silence, going over their special purpose accounts – the ones that let them pay no tax on profits delivered by Australian tax payer dollars via the PBS. Cheeky buggers. https://uploads.disquscdn.com/images/8d3bff6334fe0a19dcf9bf2e4e3c2f4a363fc3ae1fa9322cfda99385e8739b8f.png

  • Good grief, that statement from Gilead is clearly the answer to the question would you please send me a paragraph of worthless corporate spam (please feel free to meander from topic to topic) ?

  • mackak

    I expect the price of this hep C treatment in Australia will drop once most hep C patients here have been treated. Gilead’s profits are unlikely to be ongoing. They are making hay while the sun shines. By the time any action to harvest a fair profit share for Australian taxpayers is organised the profits will be much smaller.